As many campuses begin adding AI tools into their classrooms, there is immense pressure to figure out how to quickly implements these technologies in order to avoid being left behind. As digital humanists, though, we also emphasize incorporating new technology carefully and critically which often contrasts with the ways these technologies flood bland, AI generated text into our classrooms. To this end, the presenter will offer his approach and lessons learned from implementing an assignment sequence that required students to “audit” the outputs of generative AI platforms. Students worked in small groups to develop a report that assessed the accuracy and effectiveness of the genAI platforms’ source use. In treating AI technologies as a site for critical inquiry, students acquired a more nuanced understanding of AI hallucinations and a greater appreciation for how academic sources support arguments.